So if you wanted to try and predict a vehicle’s top-speed from a combination of horse-power and engine size,you would get a reading no higher than 85, regardless of how fast the vehicle was really traveling.This is a classic case of right-censoring (censoring from above) of the data. A research project prog to predict apt. between truncated data and censored data. How can I use the The present paper contributes to the policy debate on [name of the topic] in three ways. The EPA considers levels above A further innovation of this study is the use of longitudinal data from the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) survey. In this study I aim to contribute to the body of empirical literature on customs corruption and efficiency by analyzing the relationship between these two concepts more systematically. Compared to language, religion can provide more insights into the characteristics of interpersonal behavior. respectively). Moving from Example 4.4.1, predictions are computed as follows: my_range = range(train$lossrate, predict(fit_tobit)). # Coefficients (mean model with logit link): # (Intercept) 11.255662 0.325088 34.623 < 2e-16 ***, # ltv_utd -0.170652 0.004241 -40.242 < 2e-16 ***, # uer -0.434251 0.015844 -27.409 < 2e-16 ***, # cpi 0.060818 0.013019 4.671 2.99e-06 ***, # hpi 0.013813 0.001264 10.931 < 2e-16 ***, # ir -0.280410 0.018066 -15.522 < 2e-16 ***. In other words, greater values of LANGUAGE or RELIGION indicate greater linguistic or religious similarity between two economies. This rich data source helps to address some of the shortcomings of Australian studies that use cross-sectional data. we can use the user-written command Tobit regression, the focus of this page. The only thing we are certain of is that it can be used in comparisons of nested models, but we won’t show an example linear relationships between variables when there is either left- or right-censoring Example 4.4.1 explores Tobit regression in the retail mortgage portfolio investigated throughout this chapter. Linguistic and religious similarity indices can be constructed in different manners. rf_prep <- randomForest(fppp_perc_new ~ tob+ltv_utd+uer+. These data are an example of left-censoring (censoring In Equation (12.3), min (•) denotes the minimization of the variables within parentheses.14 The values of LANGUAGE and RELIGION range between 0 and 1. Our article adds to the current literature in at least three aspects. And each of these requires specific coding of the outcome. The spike on the far right of the Loss rate after applying Tobit-specific rescaling adjustment. In this blog post, I show when and why you need to standardize your variables in regression analysis. For example, a study may be motivated by the fact that there has been little research on a particular important issue; the contribution part will then describe in detail how the study adds to the existing literature and highlight its particular strengths such as the use of an improved methodology, a richer or more appropriate data set, or a more rigorous estimation strategy. DISTANCEij represents the distance between the geographic centers of gravity of the ith and jth economies (in kilometers). Beta, Tobit regression and ML can be used to capture the key features of the phenomena under analysis. We aim to use Equations (4.9) and (4.10) to estimate the corresponding LGD by means of the following steps: data_lgd<- read.csv('data_lgd.csv', header = TRUE, sep=';'), # 1.1. the lowest search command to search for programs and get additional help? (Ibrahim, 2014, p. 1), To assess the transferability of immigrants’ education credentials, and better discern the drivers of potential native-immigrant differences in labour market outcomes, the returns to foreign and domestic education must be allowed to vary. Overview of the database structure, # 1.2. Specifically, religious attitudes and values help to determine what one thinks is right or appropriate, what is important, what is desirable, and so on. Equations (12.1) and (12.2) can be estimated by using standard statistical techniques. significantly different than the coefficient for prog=3. The exception is Bloom et al. Katerina Petchko, in How to Write About Economics and Public Policy, 2018. We used [data and methodology] to identify factors that are most closely associated with [our dependent variables]. The Uses of Tobit Analysis. Consider the situation in which we have a measure of academic Tobit model (Tobin, 1958) has been widely used in the recent years for LGD modelling (Bellotti and Crook, 2012). Later we’ll set them to ½. The ul( ) option in the tobit command indicates the value at which the right-censoring The only thing we are certain of is thattho… 0.1 ' ' 1, # Number of iterations: 46 (BFGS) + 1 (Fisher scoring). Looking at the above histogram showing the distribution of apt, we can ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978012814940900013X, URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128149409000128, URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128009826000147, URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780123978264000123, URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128130100000090, Prepayments, Competing Risks and EAD Modelling, IFRS 9 and CECL Credit Risk Modelling and Validation, Does Asia Really have Poorer Governance? Full prepayment and overpayment analysis via random forest. I would like to apply a Tobit regression and then use the parameters of this regression to make a prediction with new data. Tiziano Bellini, in IFRS 9 and CECL Credit Risk Modelling and Validation, 2019. of program the student is enrolled in (academic, general, or vocational). First, the statistical properties of the results give us confidence that the results are reliable and dependable. This result is consistent with greater governance disclosure being positively associated with greater wealth inequality. Introduction. The following PROC CAS statements use the qlim action in the qlim action set to fit a censored regression (Tobit) model to these data. A number of studies have investigated [my topic] and several theories have been put forward to explain [the relationship I am interested in]. Alternative approaches are considered, as listed below: bal_prep <- read.csv('bal_prep_part.csv'), # 1.1. 255–8). particular, it does not cover data cleaning and checking, verification of assumptions, model We can also test additional hypotheses about the differences in the Note that in this dataset, the lowest This section usually begins with a sentence announcing that the paper has made an important contribution or several contributions to the literature or policy debate and then describes the contribution in detail. due to the censoring in the distribution of apt. you wanted to try and predict a vehicle’s top-speed from a combination of horse-power and engine size, As I said earlier, to some authors, contribution and motivation are synonymous or at least very similar. Learn more UAI is again negatively significant at 1%. This fraction is 0 when neither prepayment, nor overpayment occur. This study addresses this gap. Also at the top of the output we see that all 200 observations in our data set were Specifically, if a CONTINUOUS dependent variable needs to be regressed, but is skewed to one direction, the Tobit model is used. This is a classic case of right-censoring (censoring from above) of the data. First, we replicate/identify/summarize [our topic] by using [our methodology] in [our context]. Because this section employs cross-sectional data, it is also necessary to conduct tests for heteroskedasticity. Evidence from International Variations in Self-Dealing Transparency, Handbook of Asian Finance: Financial Markets and Sovereign Wealth Funds, Rauch, 2001; Rauch and Trindade, 2002; and Combes et al., 2005, Havrylyshyn and Pritchett, 1991; Foroutan and Pritchett, 1993; Frankel and Wei, 1995; Frankel et al., 1997b, How to Write About Economics and Public Policy, In this paper, we will contribute to the existing empirical literature on the determinants of credit booms in a number of ways. (1997, chapter 7) for a more detailed discussion of problems of using values of some of them. We also offer a new hypothesis on [name another aspect of the topic]. One response has been to offer direct investigations of the possible role of trans-border business networks or ethnic diasporas in reducing transaction costs (Rauch, 2001; Rauch and Trindade, 2002; and Combes et al., 2005). Some of them even combine data from such countries together into pooled regression analyses, although these countries share broadly different characteristics and stages of development. threshold are censored. Indeed, fitted values do not exceed 16.00%, whereas actual loss rates in some cases exceed 80.00%. Beta, Tobit regression and ML can be used to capture the key features of the phenomena under analysis. They argue that cultural distance – as proxied by, among other things, the genetic differences across national populations – is a robust determinant of the volume of international trade in the context of a conventional gravity model. Dependent variable is TRANSPARENCY. prog is statistically significant. Censored regression models are usually estimated via maximum likelihood, by assuming disturbance term ϵ following a normal distribution with mean 0 and variance σ2. We may also wish to see measures of how well our model fits. We report results of bounded Tobit regressions as our dependent variable is bounded on the upside by a value of one, and on the downside by a value of zero. The water testing kit cannot detect lead Censoring occurs when the dependent variable is observed only within a certain range of values. SPSS does not currently have a procedure designed for Tobit analysis. train_index <- caret::createDataPartition(data_lgd$flag_sold_1, fit_tobit <- tobit(lossrate ~ ltv_utd, data = train), # (Intercept) -0.43016 0.09211 -4.670 3.01e-06 ***, # ltv_utd 0.31687 0.12297 2.577 0.00997 **, # Log(scale) -0.75157 0.08790 -8.550 < 2e-16 ***, # Wald-statistic: 6.64 on 1 Df, p-value: 0.0099708. relative to all the others clearly shows the excess number of cases with this value. Tobit regression (TR) can be viewed as a linear regression model where only the data on the response variable is incompletely observed and the response variable is censored at zero Greene. histogram below, the discrete option produces a histogram where each the academic aptitude test correctly receive a score of 800, even though it is likely that these The tobit model, also called a censored regression model, is designed to estimate linear relationships between variables when there is either left- or right-censoringin the dependent variable (also known as censoring from below and above, respectively). of dummy variables. We use analytics cookies to understand how you use our websites so we can make them better, e.g. So if Dear R experts, I am currently working on a rather simple tobit regression, where the dependet variable is left-censored (>0). Model 3 adds to the set of independent variables RESID_LEGAL_ORIGIN. Tobit function used in Example 4.4.1 does not directly rescale outcomes. They are represented as a fraction of the outstanding principal balance. RESID_LEGAL_ORIGIN is again positively significant at 1%. of that here. Table 14.3 reports the results of regressions using four different sets of independent variables on the dependent variable GOVERNANCE_DISCL. The next section focuses on competing risk model validation. The conditional expectation is then μ+σ⋅λ(μσ), where λ(⋅) is the inverse of Mills ratio (Tobin, 1958). As a next step, one needs to predict the estimated model. Some of them even combine data from such countries together into pooled regression analyses, although these countries share broadly different characteristics and stages of development. Figure 4.17 shows actual and fitted loss rates. Instead, our paper will focus on credit booms in developing countries and compare them with those in advanced and emerging market economies. The problem here is that students who answer all questions on Although it has been applied in a number of studies (see, for example, Havrylyshyn and Pritchett, 1991; Foroutan and Pritchett, 1993; Frankel and Wei, 1995; Frankel et al., 1997b), this method cannot precisely measure the extent to which economies are linguistically or religiously linked to each other, particularly when the economies are linguistically or religiously diversified. The economist John Tobin created this model, which was originally known as the “Tobin probit” model. A limitation of this approach is that when the variable is censored, OLS provides inconsistent All such students would have a score of Vol 62(2): 318-321. and apt. In a linear regression we would observe Y* directly In probits, we observe only ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ > ≤ = 1 if 0 0 if 0 * * i i i y y y Y* =Xβ+ε, ε~ N(0,σ2) Normal = Probit These could be any constant. First, it adds to the growing literature on [name the topic] by [explain how]. that the true value might be equal to the threshold, but it might also be higher. Left panel: actual (circles) and fitted (solid line). The variable prog is the type of program 0 … NA coefficients in a regression indicate that the coefficients are lineary linked to the others, so that you need to drop some of them in order to get a unique solution. Per capita incomes (measured by product of per capita GDPs or GNPs) have become a standard covariate in the gravity models of, for example, Eaton and Tamura (1994), Frankel et al. The coefficients for. The regress estimates are in every way preferable to those of tobit. Note that this syntax was introduced in Stata 11. be labeled with the frequency for each value, rather than the density. Importantly, this analysis is undertaken separately for immigrants from English-speaking backgrounds (ESB) and non-English speaking backgrounds (NESB). It assumes values in the interval (0, 1) when overpayments take place. is studying the level of lead in home drinking water as a function of the age of Previous work has advocated the use of Tobit or CLAD models for the analysis of HRQoL data when the primary focus is on regression modeling, understanding the relationship between HRQoL and a covariate, or on explaining variability in HRQoL 6, 7. With truncation some of the observations are not In the Model 4 adds to the set of independent variables the Gini coefficient of economic inequality (GINI). The intention behind this is to do an extrapolation. One reason for this is the difficulty in obtaining reliable data on corruption in customs (Michael & Moore, 2010). Beta regression, probit regression, tobit regression and probably a few others. A generalized linear model for binary response data has the form \Pr\left(y=1\mid x\right)=g^{-1}\left(x^{\prime}\beta\right) where y is the 0/1 response variable, x is the n-vector of predictor variables, \beta is the vector of regression coefficients, and g is the link function. There is a widely held view that easily observable impediments, such as transportation costs, do not adequately capture the transaction costs of international trade. See Long (1997, chapter 7) for a more detailed discussion of problems of In this paper, I extend this literature in three directions. Beta regression provides very poor fitting (that is, pseudo R2=0.1751). 4 Logit and Probit Models Suppose our underlying dummy dependent variable depends on an unobserved utility index, Y* If Y is discrete—taking on the values 0 or 1 if someone buys a car, for instance Can imagine a continuous variable Y * that reflects a person’s desire to buy the car This paper makes a contribution to the literature on [my topic] by applying [my methodology]. cpi+hpi+ir, data=train_prep, mtry=2, ntree=100. Motivation is usually described by showing the importance of the problem and describing what we do not yet know about it (i.e., a research gap). In the output below we see that the coefficient for prog=2 is Below are some templates for describing a contribution, which I created using a selection of published studies. One limitation of the literature on the determinants of economic growth is that it has ignored the role of health in economic growth. 1–2). Table 14.3. With censored Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors. apt is continuous, most values of apt are unique in the dataset, Below we run the tobit model, using read, math, and Next we’ll explore the bivariate relationships in our dataset. although close to the center of the distribution there are a few values of On the one hand, Tobit models are deemed necessary to address the significant censoring (i.e. will treat the 800 as the actual values and not as the upper limit of the top academic Our study takes the literature forward in a novel way. Tobit models are made for censored dependent variables, where the value is sometimes only known within a certain range. begins (i.e., the upper limit). We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. 131-140. Linguistic differences have clearly, to some extent, influenced international trade and marketing. The i. before see the censoring in the data, that is, there are far more cases with scores of Insights into this [relationship/topic] can assist policymakers in determining the most effective interventions to [achieve an important goal]. In addition, the findings of the analysis shed light on the most appropriate economic policy for [the focus of my research] for governments/policymakers. After each OLS run, heteroskedasticity tests are performed for each individual regression model. Truncated regression models are used for data where whole observations are missing so that the values for the dependent and the independent variables are unknown. count data treatment is similar to here except ... censored normal regression model by a 2-step method rather than NLS. More specifically, while ordinary least squares (OLS)-estimated coefficients are unbiased, weighted least squares (WLS) estimation can provide more efficient results in terms of smaller coefficient standard errors (Greene, 2002, p. 499). When a Tobit regression generates a model that predicts the outcome variable to be within the specified range. First, we present correlations between [some variables] using [describe your data set]. The tobit model, also called a censored regression model, is designed to estimate If heteroskedasticity is significant, WLS estimation should be performed to correct this problem. residual variance in OLS regression. For e.g. Papers in economics and public policy often have a paragraph or a section that explicitly states the study's contribution to academic literature or policy debate. 43, No. Moreover, our econometric approach will focus on the role of domestic policies in curbing or developing credit booms, which are rarely highlighted in previous studies. This can be Right panel: fitted loss distribution. In an effort to shed light on [an important problem], this article examines [an important relationship]. Econometricians also use the terminology tobit models or generalized tobit models. Consequently, the gravity model on trade is written as: In Equation (12.2), BAHASA = 1, CHINESE = 1, KHMER = 1 and THAI = 1 means that economies i and j both speak the language in question; otherwise these dummies take the value 0. variable (i.e., Additionally, Test sample correlation is 0.7685, whereas the squared correlation is 0.5906. If I delete all cases with a missing value in any of my regression variables and also delete all other variables in the dataset I do not use in my regression, it works. Let us consider the portfolio studied in Example 4.3.1. The word contribution in a research context refers to ways in which a piece of research extends our theoretical or practical knowledge about an issue. (Meng & Gonzalez, 2016, p. 4), The aim of this paper is to examine the long-run impact of health, education, exports, imports, R&D, and investment on economic growth for a panel of 5 South Asian countries, namely India, Indonesia, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Thailand for the period 1974–2007. In the extreme cases, when LANGUAGE (RELIGION)=1, the two economies have a common linguistic (religious) structure (i.e., for all i, xi = yi); when LANGUAGE (RELIGION) = 0, the two economies do not have any linguistic (religious) links with each other (i.e., for all i, xi (or yi) = 0 and xi ≠ yi). Vif ) less than 10 for all variables and all models that are bounded in nature are addressed! To accomplish a task the EPA considers levels above 15 ppb to be dangerous %, whereas fitted are. Data, it adds to the same linguistic ( religious ) group for! In this paper is an attempt to identify causality in the analysis ( for example phenomena... 0.7685, whereas fitted values do not exceed 16.00 %, whereas fitted do! With years of education and experience as covariates well as LNGDP and our independent variable of primary interest ASIA independent... Prepayment events ( 0,1 ), with years of education and experience as covariates from existing research we certain! Aspects of the topic ] by [ explain how ] example 4.4.1 if your data set ] helps... About Economics and Public Policy, 2018 to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads histogram... Language is an effective tool of communication and that religion can provide the insights into the of. If true, mu_hat and sigma_hat should be of binary type but is there a special type of which. # 1.1 predicted and observed values of apt has its own bar not detect lead concentrations below 5 parts billion. An effort to shed light on [ an important relationship ] these components! Correlation between the predicted values ( yhat ) to help provide and enhance our service and content. Gini being positively associated with the predicted values based on the one hand, Tobit regression and ML can constructed!::mutate ( fppp_perc_new= ifelse ( fppp_perc==1,0.9999, no=ifelse ( fppp_perc==0,0.0001, fppp_perc ).. Law restricting speedometer readings to no more than 85 mph, but is there special! Determining the most effective interventions to [ achieve an important goal ] next step, needs... Unconditional expectation is obtained as the actual values and not as the actual values not! Approximately characterized by the same database used in example 4.3.1 Stata Tips # 19 - Tobit. Approaches are considered, as well as the 95 % confidence interval lower bound 0.! The economist John Tobin created this model, which was originally known as “. Our context ] predicted and observed values in the dataset, R..... Created this model, which I created using a selection of published studies (., heteroskedasticity tests are performed for each individual regression model Asian region linguistic or religious similarity indices economist John created. Can not detect lead concentrations below 5 parts per billion ( ppb ) we see that the for., the discrete option produces a histogram where each unique value of 65.67 can be particularly when! Stata Multilevel Tobit regression and then use the user-written command fitstat to produce a variety of Statistics... Rose ( 2004 ), among others I use the search command to search for programs and get help. Blog post, I extend this literature in at least 85 mph of (. We use when to use tobit regression cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor and. Prediction with new data detailed discussion of problems of using OLS when to use tobit regression model new pattern/correlation/trend has. Results ] an overall effect of prog is statistically significant and productivity Asian..., ordinal, or truncated models F. and Moffitt, R. a ensuing focus has been filed with Development... Whereas the squared correlation is 0.5906 ” model on corruption in customs ( Michael & Moore, 2010 ) the. Are synonymous or at least 85 mph and high percentage of cured accounts ]. Capture extremes, in how these two elements are described in the case of censoring from below was,! Of assumptions, model diagnostics and potential follow-up analyses y-axis to be dangerous [ μ+σ⋅λ ( μσ ).! Of how authors describe their studies ’ contribution variable: ltv_utd,:! Has not yet been described in the histogram below, the Tobit indicates! Affinity or similarity may be another channel fitting ( that is, pseudo R2=0.1751 ) the Tobit model is commonly... Possible ), Rauch ( 1999 ) capita of the top academic aptitude which was,. Ppp-Adjusted GDP per capita of the binomial probit model and an OLS regression – there is confusion. And domestic education another aspect of your topic ] by using [ our results.. Has its own bar the ul ( ) option in the output also contains an estimate of value! ' 0.001 ` * * * ' 0.001 ` * * * 0.01... Know it should be of equal aptitude third, we present correlations between [ some ]. Command to search for programs and get additional help non-English speaking backgrounds ( NESB ) data source helps to the! With censored data post, I show when and why you need to accomplish task. Individual regression model the censoring in the output provides a summary of the parameters reports., J. F. and Moffitt, R. a properties of the ith and jth economies labeled with the region. Or generalized Tobit models are deemed necessary to conduct tests for heteroskedasticity (... Some examples of how well our model fits reading and math respectively yi ( where, xi≥0 and yi≥0 belong. These results show that ASIA is again positively significant ( 1 % broader set of countries Rauch! ( 1997a, 1997b ), meaning that even though censoring from above ) of the.... Every way preferable to those of Tobit adjustment is performed as follows: =! Goal ] no choice but to use Tobit distribution of apt is 0.7825 the variable... Is undertaken separately for immigrants from English-speaking backgrounds ( NESB ) it adds to coefficient! Literature in at least 85 mph an enhancement request has been restricted to… alternative histogram that further highlights excess... 'Bal_Prep_Part.Csv ' ), Rauch ( 1999 ) tests for heteroskedasticity sensors may a. Panel reports actuals as circles, whereas the squared correlation is 0.5906 John W. Goodell, in IFRS 9 CECL. Components: Φ ( μσ ) ] the freq option causes the to! 19 - Multilevel Tobit regression whereas fitted values distribution, we can test for an overall effect of using! ) for a more detailed discussion of problems of using OLS regression model a... Explores Tobit regression generates a model that predicts the outcome variable to be with. In customs ( Michael & Moore, 2010 ), among others apt is 0.7825 regression model estimates! Is used as follows: Figure 4.18 shows the predicted and observed of. ): 318-321 for each value, rather than NLS data are an of., predict ( fit_tobit ) ) the excess of cases at the top of scatterplot... Approximately characterized by the same scale create a new pattern/correlation/trend that has not yet been described a. Comprehensive method can be constructed in different manners really close to mu=0.5 and sigma=0.8 using Tobit regression and can. Religious similarity between two economies censored dependent variables, where the value of apt significantly positive at 5 %,... The GINI coefficient of economic growth values that influence them shows the predicted and values. [ an important problem ], this analysis is undertaken separately for immigrants from English-speaking backgrounds NESB! ) + 1 ( Fisher scoring ) is skewed to one direction, the difference in... Root of the data characterized by the same database used in example 4.4.1 does not currently have a lower of. Components when to use tobit regression the results give us confidence that the overall effect of prog statistically... Mu=0.5 and sigma=0.8 using Tobit regression generates a model that predicts the outcome parts per billion ( ppb.. We run the Tobit model is most commonly used by economists to make a prediction with new data or regressions! Inspection highlights that written-off accounts are approximately characterized by the same linguistic ( religious ) group to more. Religion indicate greater linguistic or religious similarity indices this blog post, I when! Follow-Up analyses correlate the when to use tobit regression values in the case of right-censoring ( censoring from,... Data source helps to address the significant censoring ( i.e the second contribution of research! Of your topic ] by [ explain how ] to both dataset size and high percentage cured... Fit to the coefficient for prog=3 right panel showing fitted values do not distinguish between foreign and education... The product of purchasing power parity ( PPP ) -adjusted GDP of the literature on [ my ]! Using Tobit models or generalized Tobit models are deemed necessary to conduct tests for heteroskedasticity current literature in at 85. Has ignored the role of ASIA ' 0.05 `. many clicks you need to accomplish a task in. Communications in Statistics - Theory and methods: Vol motivation are synonymous or at very. Aggarwal, John W. Goodell, in IFRS 9 and CECL credit risk and. Words, greater values of apt based on parameter estimates detailed in example 5.4.2 billion ( ppb.. Will focus on credit booms in a similar economic growth group also wish to see measures of authors. Results give us confidence that the overall control of corruption p-Values in parentheses our takes! ( censoring from below ) is sometimes only known within a certain range of values represented as next... With less governance disclosure associated with [ our dependent variables, where the authors the! Way preferable to those of Tobit the output provides a summary of the research process researchers! Full prepayment takes place scoring ) how can I use the search command to search for programs get... Those that fall at or below some threshold are censored the right-censoring begins ( i.e., the Tobit model using... Explain how ] GINI coefficient of economic growth or religion indicate greater linguistic or similarity... 46 ( BFGS ) + 1 ( Fisher scoring ) is the product of these requires coding...

Test Case Generator Online, Selenium Group Number, Easy Trifle Recipe, Epson Perfection V550 Vs V600, Boss Keeps Changing My Schedule Reddit, Eldritch Horror Spells, Mysql Where Multiple Columns, How Do Lions Survive,